"The advent of subscription licenses changed how we recognize revenue.”
The software industry, which used to operate on a perpetual license model, gradually shifted towards subscription and usage-based models, largely facilitated by cloud technology. This change made revenue recognition less about outright sales and more about managing customer relationships and service delivery over time.
The subscription model has certainly gone on to simplify financial management in the enterprise world. But it has also introduced newer complexities in tracking and recognizing revenues, based on usage. Some of them include — complex contract arrangements, regulatory and compliance issues, integration of business models.
The onus is now on having transparent and reliable systems to manage these transactions.
Here are a few things to think about while trying to navigate modern revenue recognition
- Advanced accounting systems — Utilizing revenue recognition software that can handle multi-element contracts and complex billing scenarios is crucial. These systems should automate processes and ensure accuracy in the allocation and recognition of revenue.
- Regular training and upskilling — Ensuring that finance and accounting teams are up-to-date with the latest regulatory changes and technological advancements. Continuous education helps in adapting to new standards and understanding complex contracts better.
- Clear documentation and transparency — Maintaining detailed documentation of contracts and performance obligations, along with transparent financial reporting that clarifies revenue recognition practices to stakeholders.
- Aligning revenue recognition with business strategy — By focusing on the economic rationale behind transactions, companies can better manage revenue recognition, ensuring it reflects true business activities and customer engagements.
These are only a few. We believe there is far more importance to integrating financial practices with business objectives to manage several of your different revenue recognition complexities.
We spoke with Viraj Patel, CFO at Signeasy, while he spoke extensively on the importance of understanding a business's economic model for successful revenue recognition. Our discussion with him not only clarified the complexities of revenue recognition but also highlighted its evolution and its ongoing adaptation in the face of technological advancement.
Speakers:
Viraj Patel, CFO, and Board Advisor
- Four decades of experience in the world of finance
- CFO and Board Member with PE/SPAC/IPO experience; Public and Startup Companies
Apurv Bansal and Saurabh Agrawal, Founders at Zenskar
Webinar Summary
Q. What is revenue recognition and why is it important?
Revenue recognition is the process of recognizing revenue from a sale at the right time, based on a consistent set of accounting principles. It’s important because it ensures financial statements are accurate, consistent, and reflect the true economic performance of a business, ensuring compliance with regulations.
Q. How has revenue recognition evolved over the years?
Traditionally, businesses would recognize revenue when a sale occurred, typically for physical products. However, with the rise of software and cloud technologies, revenue recognition became more complex, especially with the introduction of subscription-based and hybrid business models where the timing of revenue recognition changes.
Q. What are the key differences between hardware and software business models?
Hardware business models were straightforward, where businesses sold a physical product, and revenue was recognized upfront. In contrast, software models introduced complexities due to licensing, where the software could be bundled with hardware. With the rise of cloud computing, this became more nuanced, requiring businesses to bifurcate the hardware, software, and services for proper revenue recognition.
Q. How does revenue recognition work in a business with multiple components, such as hardware, software, and services?
In contracts that include hardware, software, and services, companies must bifurcate the revenue based on the individual components. For instance, revenue from software may be recognized over time, services may be recognized as they’re provided, and hardware revenue is recognized when the title passes. This ensures accurate financial reporting.
Q. How does the subscription model affect revenue recognition?
In a subscription model, revenue is recognized gradually over the contract term as the service is provided. Unlike a one-time sale where revenue is recognized upfront, subscriptions allow for more predictable, recurring revenue recognition, often based on usage or time period, providing vendors and customers with flexibility.
Q. What are the challenges associated with subscription-based revenue recognition?
Subscription-based models require constant tracking of usage to ensure accurate billing and revenue recognition. Businesses need tools to track usage accurately, especially if there are overages or additional charges. The challenge lies in ensuring that revenue is recognized consistently and accurately, even when services fluctuate month-to-month.
Q. How do consumption-based models impact revenue recognition?
Consumption-based models, such as AWS or cloud software, charge customers based on actual usage, which can vary from month to month. Revenue is recognized as the service is used, which requires accurate tracking and real-time recognition. Unlike fixed subscription models, this can make forecasting and accounting more complex.
Q. How can companies manage revenue recognition in consumption-based models?
Companies must use advanced tools to track consumption in real-time and adjust invoices accordingly. If usage exceeds agreed-upon parameters, the system must identify the overage and ensure it is invoiced and recognized in the correct period. This requires robust infrastructure and tools to maintain compliance with accounting standards.
Q. What role does economic modeling play in revenue recognition?
Understanding the economic model behind a business is essential to accurate revenue recognition. The accounting rules may be complex, but they align with the fundamental business cycle—making, selling, and delivering products and services. A solid grasp of the business model helps ensure compliance and enables better decision-making when structuring deals.
Q. How do you manage revenue recognition in hybrid business models, like subscription and consumption-based pricing?
In hybrid models, revenue recognition becomes more intricate. A company may sell software on a subscription basis but charge based on usage for certain features. Proper tracking mechanisms need to be in place to account for both recurring subscription fees and usage-based revenue, ensuring accurate and compliant financial reporting.
Q. How does cloud technology affect revenue recognition?
Cloud technology simplifies revenue recognition for subscription models by allowing companies to deliver software and services remotely, eliminating the need for physical installations. Cloud-based services are more flexible, enabling vendors to charge based on usage and ensuring that updates and features are included as part of the subscription at no extra cost.
Q. Why is accuracy in revenue recognition critical for public companies?
Public companies must be highly accurate in revenue recognition because errors can lead to material misstatements in their financial statements, which could trigger restatements, fines, or loss of investor trust. Accurate revenue reporting is essential to maintaining regulatory compliance and the company’s financial integrity.
Q. How can small companies with complex pricing models manage revenue recognition effectively?
Smaller companies need to ensure they have the right systems in place to track different types of revenue streams. For complex pricing models, this means having tools to monitor subscription usage, overages, and discounts. It’s also critical to regularly communicate with customers to ensure revenue is recognized accurately and consistently.
Q. What tools or processes are needed to manage revenue recognition in companies with subscription-based pricing models?
To manage revenue recognition, companies need reliable tools that track both the subscription and any additional usage. This includes automated invoicing systems, real-time usage tracking, and proper reporting mechanisms. It's essential for businesses to implement a system that integrates billing with their accounting software to ensure compliance.
Q. How should a company track usage and adjust invoices accordingly in a consumption-based model?
A company must track customer usage through APIs or similar tools that provide data on the services consumed. These tools need to automatically trigger invoices for any additional usage beyond the base subscription, ensuring that revenue recognition is adjusted as consumption grows, while remaining compliant with accounting standards.
Q. How do businesses ensure compliance with revenue recognition standards in dynamic pricing models?
Businesses must regularly audit their pricing models, ensuring that the pricing tiers and any usage-based charges are well-documented and transparent. They need systems that track the specific terms of each contract and automatically recognize revenue as specified, ensuring compliance with standards like ASC 606 or IFRS 15.
Q. Why is understanding the economic model crucial for revenue recognition in software businesses?
Understanding the economic model is essential because it aligns with the principles of revenue recognition. For example, if you know that a customer is billed based on usage, you can ensure that revenue is recognized as the service is consumed, rather than upfront. This understanding helps companies build accurate financial models and maintain compliance.
Q. How can vendors ensure that subscription and consumption-based models are financially sustainable?
Vendors need to strike a balance between pricing models that ensure sustainable revenue while being flexible for customers. Subscription models should offer predictable income streams, while usage-based pricing allows vendors to capitalize on customer demand. Accurate tracking and forecasting are crucial to ensure profitability and minimize revenue leakage.
.jpg)
